• Pink Hilite Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Taupe Sparkle Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Gold Chubby Pencil by Indigo Private Label CosmeticsChubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • White Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Branch Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Black Shimmer Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Bronze Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Charcoal Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Larkspur Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Moss Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Grape Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Hearthstone Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Natural Brown Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Supernova Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Kindling Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Black Matte Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Teal Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Lilac Shimmer Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Magnolia Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Ivory Sparkle Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Avocado Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
  • Sapphire Chubby Pencil is Cruelty-free cosmetics by Indigo Private Label Cosmetics
1 1

Indigo Private Label

Chubby Eye Pencil

Chubby Eye Pencil

PINK HILITE
WHITE HILITE
BLACK SHIMMER
BRANCH
BRONZE
CHARCOAL
GOLD FOIL
GRAPE
HEARTHSTONE
IVORY SPARKLE
KINDLING
LARKSPUR
LILAC SHIMMER
MAGNOLIA
MOSS
NATURAL BLACK
NATURAL BROWN
AVOCADO
SAPPHIRE
SUPERNOVA
TAUPE SPARKLE
TEAL

Minimum order is 1 Units

Total $12.40 $12.40 /unit
Total $12.40 $12.40 /unit
Made in USA
Cruelty-free
Eco-friendly
Safe
View full details

Why Chubby Eye Pencil?

Create stunning eye looks in seconds with our bestselling chubby eye pencil. This oversized pencil delivers rich, creamy color that glides on smoothly and sets to a long-wearing, crease-proof finish. The jumbo format covers the lid quickly while the twist-up design eliminates sharpening. Available in versatile shades from soft neutrals to bold metallics, this fool-proof formula works for everyone from makeup beginners to professionals.

Why Chubby Eye Pencil?

Why Indigo Private Label?

Our chubby eye pencil revolutionizes eye makeup by combining ease, speed, and performance. Apply directly to lids, blend with fingertips if desired, and let set for all-day wear. The waterproof, smudge-proof formula won't crease, fade, or transfer. Use alone for quick, polished looks or as a base for powder shadows. Perfect for private label brands targeting busy customers who want beautiful eyes without complicated techniques or tools.

Why Indigo Private Label?

Frequently Asked Questions

Have questions about our skincare products? We have you covered.

A chubby eye pencil is a jumbo, crayon-style stick with a much wider barrel than a standard liner, built for fast, bold application that doubles as eyeliner, cream eyeshadow, or a highlighter. The oversized tip covers the lid quickly and never needs the precision a slim pencil requires.

No, this version may contain carmine, a pigment derived from insects, so it is not vegan, though it is certified cruelty-free, made in the USA, and eco-friendly. If a fully vegan formula matters to your line, the brand also carries a separate Vegan Chubby Eye Pencil made without any animal-derived ingredients.

This pencil uses a twist-up mechanism rather than a standard wood pencil format, so it never needs sharpening at all. If you do source a jumbo pencil elsewhere that requires sharpening, look for a sharpener sized 10 to 12mm to fit the wider barrel.

Yes, it is formulated to apply creamy at first, then set into a waterproof, smudge-proof finish that resists creasing, fading, and transfer once it settles. Waterproof formulas hold up against moisture while smudge-proof formulas resist oil and friction, and this pencil is built to handle both.

Long-wear, crease-proof formulas like this one are designed to hold their place better than standard creamy liners, since they set to a finish that resists oil breakdown throughout the day. For extra staying power on oily lids, setting the pencil with a matching powder eyeshadow on top helps lock it in further.

Yes, apply it close to the lash line and blend upward and outward with a smudge brush or cotton swab while the formula is still workable, since it sets relatively quickly once applied. Because the tip is broader than a slim liner, it also makes filling in extra lid space for a smoky base faster.

The formula includes castor oil and jojoba esters for glide, candelilla wax for structure, sunflower seed oil and corn starch for texture, rosemary leaf extract as a natural preservative, and mineral pigments like mica, titanium dioxide, and zinc oxide for color payoff.

It's available in 22 shades spanning mattes, shimmers, and metallics. The minimum order is 1 unit, with a buyer-supplied barrel or the black sharpener barrel option, and volume pricing improves starting at 12 units.

Contact Us

Please include brand name and website if applicable and a member of our team will get backto you shortly. We look forward to connecting with you to discuss any upcoming projectsor answer any questions you may have.